Skip to content

October 11, 2012


More On the Always-Relevant Jeremiah

by Brendan

Back on March 28th (you could look it up), I posted on poet Gerard Manley Hopkins’ poem commenting on the passage in the Book of Jeremiah in which the prophet politely complains to God about the fact that, well, “sinners ways prosper.”  (Hopkins begins by writing, “Thou are indeed just, Lord\ If I contend with thee.\  But Sir, my cause is just.”)

The Prophet Jeremiah

Oddly, I woke up this morning thinking about that posting, that Scripture passage, and  that poem.  More oddly still, I came back home a little while ago and picked up my Bible to continue reading (3 chapters a day and 4 on Sunday takes a person through the whole Scripture in a year — it’s an ancient spiritual practice).

And guess which chapter came up today in my reading?.  Right, the chapter I referred to above, Jeremiah 12; which begins, in the New American Bible version I’m using,

You would be in the right, O Lord,

if I should dispute with you;

even so, I must discuss the case with you.

Michelangelo’s Jeremiah

Why does the way of the godless prosper,

why live all the treacherous in contentment?

The first 12 chapters in Jeremiah, and the chapters immediately following the quote above,are basically about how all Israel itself has abandoned the worship of the true God, their covenant, and they’re doing ANYTHING BUT prospering — there’s drought, there’s sterility, there are external threats from warlike nations, and so forth.

But what the prophet is referring to in his complaint to God is a local, personal situation — Jeremiah feels besieged by just about everybody, because just about nobody seems to be happy with him pointing out their wrongdoing and threatening them with dire results if they don’t repent.  Jeremiah is worse than a gadfly; he’s a true thorn in the side of everyone, and he expresses fears for his life repeatedly throughout the book named after him.  In short, he feels as if he’s not getting anywhere and that the “godless” and “treacherous” are doing better than just fine.

So he complains to God; but briefly, and then goes back to discussing Israel’s problems rather than his own.

Read more from Spirituality
1 Comment Post a comment
  1. Scott McNairy
    Dec 30 2012

    A late discovery that maybe the bloggers will read someday. Staying in Glenwood Springs, CO about 140 mi. From our mate Quimby’s retreat in Grand Junction. Revisiting Aspen/Snowmass after 25 years for our teens pleasure. Such an indulgence palace for the non-English speaking. My twin teen snowboarders feel misplaced but enjoy the powder untouched by the elites who dare not shred it. Nirvana to be shared on GoPro/ YouTube but missing the shared experience of companions with whom they know. It is like a tree falling in the forest and nobody hears it.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Note: HTML is allowed. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to comments

%d bloggers like this: